My mom recently gave me a terracotta apple baker ... so I was DELIGHTED when Susanne at Arthur Morgan House Inn sent me a recipe that gave me the opportunity to use it.

As I read on through the recipe I realized it was stove top.  Bummer!  So I decided to try it both ways ... sauteed and oven baked.

A sort of apple cook-off.  A contest.  A duel.  An absolute apple taste test.

Maybe it's because I was just having one of those frustrating weeks where stress started creeping in because I had a lot of projects started and nothing finished.  So slicing and chopping apples was just the outlet I needed for releasing some energy.

Get your apples on the counter.  LOTS and LOTS of apples.  Any variety that's available.  A mix of tart and sweet.  I used gala, granny smith and fuji.

The recipe was sort of wingin' it ... no exact measurements.  It's a fun way to cook ... a dash here and a dash there ... but difficult to duplicate and share!  Susanne is delightful through email, and I can tell she's been making these for so long that it just comes naturally to her.  So, I've "winged it" and made up some measurements form Susanne's list of ingredients that worked pretty well and added one of my own ... cinnamon.

You'll need ... about a teaspoon of freshly grated nutmeg (our local grocer didn't carry whole nutmeg, so I used some already grated.) Also, about a teaspoon of freshly grated ginger (another item our grocer was out of.  Sheesh! And I love freshly grated ginger.  I was too impatient to wait 2 days for their next shipment to come in, so I used some I had in my spice rack as a standby.)A teaspoon of cinnamon (after I re-read the recipe, realized this was my own addition!  Whoops!  I just couldn't imagine apples without cinnamon). Add to that some lemon juice, vanilla and a handful of raisins.

I used the same ingredients for baking as I did for the stove top  ... we'll see which produces a better apple!  (Hint: It takes a little more time, but so worth it.  Follow along ...)

I'm gonna show you the baked apples first, then the sauteed Arthur Morgan House Apples.

For the baked apples, I sliced and cored them but kept the peels in tact.  I did it such a way that the whole apple was still connected by the skin at the bottom.  A little tricky, as you have to sort of pull the apple back through the slicer.  Don't pull your finger through at the same time!  Unless ... of course ... you're making this recipe for Halloween and are going for the whole bloody-apples-with-finger-bits kind of dish.  But that's just plain gross.

I thought it would later make a nice presentation with a big scoop of ice cream in the middle.

I needed a little leverage on some of these firm apples, so I stepped up on a stool to throw my weight into this coring thing.  So THIS is how Julia Child felt hovering over her counter tops.  Aaah.  It's nice to be tall ... even just for a moment.

All the apples nestled nicely in their little baker.

Despite my unfruitful search for fresh ginger and whole nutmeg to grind ... I did find a lonely lemon.  I roll lemons on the cutting board a bit to get it a bit more juiced up.

Here's where I let the photos tell the story for a bit.  A little lemon, a dash of vanilla ...

GASP!  At this point I remembered my spices.  Too late.  The apples have already started soaking up the lemon and vanilla and boy-o-boy did it pour quick.   Ah well.  Rethink.  Revise.  Sprinkling it is.  I guess it is possible that the spices would have just stuck to the bowl?  (making myself feel better anyway!) Now I'll just be more precise with how to sprinkle them?  At least each apple got a little extra love and some undivided spice attention.

Well ain't that symmetrical?

Strategically place some raisins and you're ready to go!

We are now up to our elbows in apples and I realized I got a little carried away.  For the sauteed apples I should have PEELED them first, then chopped.   Now we've got to peel them all individually and I'm having flashbacks to stories of my grandfather talking about how peeling potatoes in the army was sort of a punishment.  I guess I'm paying my penance  for any wrong doings of the week.  I may have to pour some autumn sangria to get through this tedious task!

Assuming you're smarter than me, and actually peeled your apples before slicing, then this process should be pretty quick.  Next, add your naked apples to a warmed up saute pan (medium heat) with the same juice/vanilla/spice concoction listed above for the baked apples.

Pour on the raisins ...

Reduce heat to low/medium and stir every 5 to 10 minutes until the apples have absorbed all the spices and they turn into a gooey compote.

So, is it the sauteed apples ...

Or the baked apples that passed the taste test?

Both were excellent and immediately devoured with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.  If you're into the dessert for breakfast sort-of-thing.  Susanne says guests love it served warm either solo, with cereal or yogurt.  I would even spoon it on toast.

The baked apples were a little less sweet.  The sauteed much more tender and syrupy.  Hands down, I'd say I preferred the stove top version. Turned out much tastier!  Well, at least I can use the apple baker as a serving dish!

Arthur Morgan House Apples

Peel and slice apples of several varieties into a large sauce pan with grated fresh ginger, fresh grating of nutmeg, a handful of raisins, a splash of lemon juice, and a dribble of good-quality vanilla (Susanne recommends Sunny Caribee's Vanilla Vanilla from the British Virgin Islands).  Cook over low-medium heat until apples are tender.  Taste as you go and you'll find the right balance of flavors.

**Susanne recommends mixing a little of this compote into the batter next time you make banana bread. Mmm.

###

Share on Twitter